뉴스필드

노동·인권 전문지

English Edition

48 Killed in Collapse of Bridge Co-Built by Hyundai Engineering & Construction… Indian Government Panel Cites Responsibility, Legal Disputes Continue

English translation of the original Korean report. Images and source documents may contain Korean text.

인도 대법원 판결문 7쪽에서 정부 조사위원회 판단을 인용하며 현대건설·갬몬 공동시공사에 교량 붕괴의 1차적 책임이 있다고 적시한 부분. 빨간 박스는 해당 핵심 문단. (출처: 인도 대법원 판결문)
An excerpt from page 7 of a Supreme Court of India judgment citing the government expert committee’s finding that the Hyundai Engineering & Construction–Gammon joint venture bore primary responsibility for the bridge collapse. The red box highlights the key paragraph. (Source: Supreme Court of India judgment)

India’s Supreme Court Overturns Insurance Payout Ruling… Consultancy Fee Dispute Involving Supervision Firm Also Goes to Appeal

Legal disputes related to an accident that killed 48 workers on a bridge jointly constructed by Hyundai Engineering & Construction in India are continuing, as the incident enters its 17th year.

According to judgments of the Supreme Court of India and the Delhi High Court examined on the 20th, 48 workers died when part of a bridge under construction over the Chambal River in Kota, Rajasthan, India, collapsed on December 24, 2009.

The bridge was being jointly constructed at the time by Hyundai Engineering & Construction and Indian construction company Gammon India, and an Indian government expert committee concluded in August 2010 that a combination of structural instability, design defects and construction-quality problems had contributed to the collapse.

In particular, the committee stated that the Hyundai Engineering & Construction–Gammon joint venture bore primary responsibility for the collapse because it had allowed the structure to reach an unstable condition without taking adequate safety precautions.

2009년 12월 24일 인도 라자스탄주 코타의 참발강에서 현대건설과 갬몬인디아가 공동 시공하던 교량이 붕괴해 노동자 48명이 숨진 사고 현장. 무너진 교량 구조물과 철골 잔해가 강변에 쌓여 있다. (사진=Sam Panthaky/AFP/Getty Images, 글로벌뉴스 보도 화면 캡처)
The site of the December 24, 2009, bridge collapse over the Chambal River in Kota, Rajasthan, India, where 48 workers died while Hyundai Engineering & Construction and Gammon India were jointly constructing the bridge. Collapsed bridge structures and steel framework debris are piled along the riverbank. (Photo: Sam Panthaky/AFP/Getty Images, screenshot from Global News coverage)

Shortly after the accident, Hyundai Engineering & Construction said it believed that a section handled by the local company had collapsed first, triggering a chain collapse, while the expert committee also pointed to responsibility on the part of the design consultant and the supervision consultant.

■ Insurance Payout Ruling Overturned… Supervision Fee Litigation Continues in 2026

On May 16, 2024, the Supreme Court of India overturned a 2023 decision by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission ordering an insurer to pay insurance proceeds to the joint contractors, including Hyundai Engineering & Construction.

The Supreme Court held that insurance policy exclusions relating to design defects and other issues applied, citing the findings of the government expert committee and the insurer’s loss assessor.

Subsequently, on August 3 this year, the Delhi High Court upheld the arbitration ruling concerning payments for the construction period in a consultancy fee dispute between the National Highways Authority of India and the joint venture of The Louis Berger Group Inc. and COWI A/S, while setting aside the ruling concerning operation and maintenance consultancy fees.

The National Highways Authority of India appealed the decision, and on November 6 the court ordered it to submit a summary of its arguments concerning the payment claims and supporting documentation, scheduling the next hearing for February 23, 2027.

However, the ongoing appeal concerns a consultancy fee dispute between the project owner and the supervision firm, rather than proceedings seeking to hold Hyundai Engineering & Construction liable for the accident, and does not involve determining criminal liability for the workers’ deaths or compensation for their bereaved families.

LEAVE A RESPONSE

이메일 주소는 공개되지 않습니다. 필수 필드는 *로 표시됩니다

ESC 또는 배경 클릭하여 닫기