뉴스필드

노동·인권 전문지

English Edition

Hana Securities Listed Homeplus Under ‘Safety Net to Protect Principal and Interest’…Homeplus Sought Rehabilitation Just Seven Days After Issuance

English translation of the original Korean report. Images and source documents may contain Korean text.

하나증권의 홈플러스 전단채 상품설명서에는 원리금 보전을 위한 ‘안전망’으로 정의한 신용보강 항목에 ‘홈플러스㈜의 신용’이 기재돼 있다. 그러나 신용보강 주체로 표시된 홈플러스는 해당 상품이 2025년 2월 25일 발행된 지 불과 7일 만인 3월 4일 회생절차를 신청했다. (출처=하나증권 상품설명서)
Hana Securities’ product description for Homeplus short-term notes lists ‘Homeplus Co., Ltd.’s credit’ under ‘credit enhancement,’ which the document defines as a ‘safety net’ for preserving principal and interest. However, Homeplus, identified as the credit-enhancement provider, applied for rehabilitation proceedings on March 4, just seven days after the product was issued on February 25, 2025. (Source: Hana Securities product description)

Company With Debt Due Within a Year Four Times Its Current Assets Listed Under Credit Enhancement…Controversy Over 219.9 Billion Won in Short-Term Note Sales

Hana Securities (President and CEO Seong-muk Kang) listed Homeplus in the credit-enhancement field of its product description for Homeplus card-payment short-term notes, defining credit enhancement as a ‘safety net’ to protect principal and interest. That same Homeplus applied for rehabilitation proceedings just seven days after the product was issued.

About six months before the securities were sold, Homeplus already had liabilities due within one year exceeding four times the value of its assets convertible into cash within a year. In other words, the company listed as a safeguard for investors’ principal was itself struggling to manage its own debt.

하나증권의 홈플러스 전단채 상품설명서에 실린 ‘발행 구조 예시’. 별도의 신용보강기관이 유동화회사에 지급보증과 신용공여 등을 제공하는 것으로 그려져 있지만, 홈플러스는 실제 해당 전단채에 지급보증이나 자금보충 등 신용보강을 제공한 사실이 없다고 밝혔다. (출처=하나증권 상품설명서)
An ‘Issuance Structure Example’ in Hana Securities’ product description for Homeplus short-term notes. The diagram depicts a separate credit-enhancement institution providing payment guarantees, credit facilities and other support to the securitization company, but Homeplus said it had not provided any credit enhancement, including payment guarantees or funding support, for these notes. (Source: Hana Securities product description)

According to Hana Securities’ product description and the Financial Supervisory Service’s Electronic Disclosure System on the 17th, Hana Securities included a separate ‘credit enhancement’ field in the issue information for the ‘SY Plus First’ asset-backed electronic short-term notes (ABSTB), listing ‘Homeplus Co., Ltd.’s credit’ apart from the underlying asset, ‘card payment receivables.’ The product was issued on February 25, 2025, with principal repayable three months later and an A3 credit rating.

The same document defined credit enhancement as ‘putting a safety net in place’ so that the value of principal and interest could be preserved despite losses. Its issuance-structure diagram depicted a credit-enhancement institution providing payment guarantees and credit facilities to the securitization company. Under the document’s definition, Homeplus should have entered into an agreement to repay the debt on behalf of another party, but Homeplus said it had never provided payment guarantees or funding support for these notes.

When credit enhancement is actually provided, a bond’s rating rises in line with the creditworthiness of the institution providing the enhancement. Korea Investors Service’s rating methodology also defines a credit-enhancement institution as a ‘third-party institution.’ However, these notes’ A3 rating was identical to Homeplus’ own A3 short-term credit rating. A3 is the lowest tier of investment-grade ratings.

■ Homeplus, Listed as a ‘Safety Net,’ Had Short-Term Debt Four Times Its Assets Six Months Before Sales

홈플러스가 2024년 5월 31일 공개한 감사보고서에 따르면 2024년 2월 말 기준 유동자산은 8374억원(위)에 그친 반면, 1년 안에 갚아야 할 유동부채는 3조4962억원(아래)으로 유동자산의 4배를 넘었다. 이는 하나증권이 홈플러스 전단채를 판매하기 약 반년 전에 공개된 재무상태다. (출처=금융감독원 전자공시시스템)
According to Homeplus’ audit report released on May 31, 2024, current assets totaled just 837.4 billion won as of the end of February 2024 (above), while current liabilities due within one year amounted to 3.4962 trillion won (below), more than four times current assets. This financial condition was disclosed about six months before Hana Securities began selling Homeplus short-term notes. (Source: Financial Supervisory Service Electronic Disclosure System)

According to Homeplus’ audit report released on May 31, 2024, the company recorded a net loss of 574.2 billion won for the period from March 2023 to February 2024, marking its second consecutive year of substantial losses. Total equity fell 70% in one year, from 871.2 billion won to 265.3 billion won.

Current liabilities due within one year amounted to 3.4962 trillion won, while current assets that could be converted into cash within one year totaled just 837.4 billion won. The company held 155.8 billion won in cash and had 1.4632 trillion won in borrowings, and it had failed to comply with bank loan covenants at the end of the preceding year. Debt arising from purchase-only cards, which underpinned the short-term notes, also surged 75% in one year, from 201 billion won to 351.3 billion won.

하나증권의 홈플러스 전단채 상품설명서에는 ‘신용보강: 홈플러스㈜의 신용’이라고 기재돼 있다(위). 그러나 신용보강 주체로 표시된 홈플러스는 해당 상품이 2025년 2월 25일 발행된 지 불과 7일 만인 3월 4일 회생절차 개시 결정을 받았다(아래). (출처=하나증권 상품설명서·홈플러스 감사보고서)
Hana Securities’ product description for Homeplus short-term notes states ‘Credit enhancement: Homeplus Co., Ltd.’s credit’ (above). However, Homeplus, identified as the credit-enhancement provider, received a court decision to commence rehabilitation proceedings on March 4, just seven days after the product was issued on February 25, 2025 (below). (Sources: Hana Securities product description and Homeplus audit report)

In the same report, Homeplus stated that it accounted for payments made using purchase-only cards as liabilities owed to financial institutions. When a company enters rehabilitation proceedings, repayment of debts owed to financial institutions is suspended. Korea Ratings reportedly notified Homeplus of preliminary findings indicating a credit-rating downgrade on February 25, the issuance date, and Homeplus applied for rehabilitation on March 4.

A total of 401.9 billion won in these short-term notes, issued between December 2024 and February 25, 2025, remained unpaid. An emergency response committee representing affected investors said Hana Securities had sold 219.9 billion won of the notes to 346 individual investors and 63 corporate entities.

Responding to questions from this publication, Hana Securities said, ‘Securitized securities are structured so that repayment of the underlying assets is based on the debtor’s creditworthiness,’ explaining that the phrase ‘Homeplus’ credit’ reflected this structure and was used in accordance with the Korea Securities Depository’s disclosure standards. The firm also said that the product description disclosed the possibility of principal loss and investment risks, and that Homeplus executives were under investigation on suspicion of issuing the securities without disclosing information including a credit-rating downgrade.

However, Hana Securities placed that wording in the credit-enhancement field rather than the underlying-assets field. In its third-quarter report released on the 13th, Hana Securities described the product as ‘Homeplus own-credit short-term notes,’ and two lawsuits seeking damages for mis-selling and deception, filed by customers who purchased the notes, are pending at the first-instance court.

The Financial Supervisory Service reportedly summoned Hana Securities investors on the 11th to determine whether they had received the product description and been informed of credit risks. Hana Securities had also received an institutional warning from the FSS in August 2022 over the mis-selling of private funds.

Hana Securities is a wholly owned subsidiary of Hana Financial Group (Chairman Ham Young-joo). Hana Securities said it was difficult to comment on whether it would compensate investors or on specific compensation measures because the FSS’s sanctions review process was underway. The emergency response committee is demanding that the securities firms that sold the notes provide upfront compensation equivalent to 100% of investors’ principal.

ESC 또는 배경 클릭하여 닫기